Nominees
2012 Finalists
| Shawn Baker | Sr. | Norwich University |
| Aleca Hughes | Sr. | Yale University |
| Cody Reichard | Sr. | Miami University |
| Kevin McNamara | Sr. | Colgate University |
| Tucker Mullin | Jr. | St. Anselm College |
2012 Nominees
| Shawn Baker | Sr. | Norwich University |
| Yuri Bouharevich | Sr. | Quinnipiac University |
| Isaiah Carlson | Jr. | Salve Regina University |
| Jordy Christian | Sr. | St. Cloud State University |
| Brianna Delaney | Sr. | Robert Morris University |
| Nick Dineen | Sr. | Colorado College |
| Bobby Farnham | Sr. | Brown University |
| Sam Goodwin | Sr. | Niagara University |
| Alyssa Grogan | Sr. | University of Minnesota |
| Lindsey Gullett | Sr. | Castleton State College |
| Kaitlin Hayes | Sr. | Castleton State College |
| Aleca Hughes | Sr. | Yale University |
| Shawn Hunwick | Sr. | University of Michigan |
| Sean Lorenz | Sr. | University of Notre Dame |
| Kyle Maggard | Sr. | U.S. Military Academy |
| Kevin McNamara | Sr. | Colgate University |
| Daman Milson | Sr. | College of St. Scholastica |
| Tucker Mullin | Jr. | St. Anselm College |
| Trevor Nill | Sr. | Michigan State University |
| Ashley Norum | Sr. | University of Maine |
| Kaare Odegard | Jr. | University of Alaska |
| Cody Reichard | Sr. | Miami University |
| Furman Smith | Sr. | Robert Morris University |
2011 Finalists
| Brooks Dyroff | So. | Boston College |
| Alex Higgins | Sr. | Saint Michael’s College |
| Aleca Hughes | Jr. | Yale University |
| Sam Kuzyk | Sr. | Adrian College |
| Tucker Mullin | So. | St. Anselm College |
| Trevor Nill | Jr. | Michigan State University |
| Whitney Pappas | Sr. | Robert Morris University |
| Brigid O’Gorman | Sr. | Connecticut College |
2011 Nominees
| Jenni Bauer | Sr. | Niagara University |
| Jackie Berglass | Sr. | Williams College |
| Stephane Boileau | Sr. | Union College |
| Joseph Calvi | Sr. | Bentley University |
| Isaiah Carlson | So. | Salve Regina University |
| Ryan Corry | Sr. | SUNY Plattsburgh |
| Paul Dainton | Sr. | University of Massachusetts |
| Brooks Dyroff | So. | Boston College |
| Kristin Faber | Jr. | University of Wisconsin - Eau Claire |
| Alyssa Grogan | Jr. | University of Minnesota |
| Alex Higgins | Sr. | Saint Michael’s College |
| Tanner House | Sr. | University of Maine |
| Aleca Hughes | Jr. | Yale University |
| Sam Kuzyk | Sr. | Adrian College |
| Ciara Lee | Sr. | Wayne State University |
| Mario Mjelleli | Sr. | Augsburg College |
| Ron Meyers | Jr. | University of Alaska |
| Scott Moser | Jr. | Canisius College |
| Tucker Mullin | So. | St. Anselm College |
| Trevor Nill | Jr. | Michigan State University |
| Whitney Pappas | Sr. | Robert Morris University |
| Brigid O’Gorman | Sr. | Connecticut College |
| Cody Reichard | Jr. | Miami University |
| Ben Ryan | Sr. | University of Notre Dame |
| Paul Zanette | Sr. | Niagara University |
